Wouldn't it be nice, just for once, to go a week or two without officiating controversies dominating the Premier League agenda? John Brooks' performance on Saturday evening raised enough eyebrows; but even his (and his colleagues') staggering ineptitude was comprehensively eclipsed by an absolute travesty of a decision at Old Trafford on Sunday.
I'll get back to the latter later on, but let's first concentrate on what we're really here for - which is Arsenal maintaining their 100% record at Sunderland. A ground, by the way, where you may recall they dropped points very late on last season' and at which they had to really battle for the result. And up, as they were, against not only a very physical and determined Sunderland team who had almost exclusively been given the week off by their manager despite having a Carabao Cup tie, but also a Premier League/television schedule which meant that they had to get back from Naples on Wednesday night and prepare for a tough away game just 72 hours later. Plus a referee who did his absolute utmost to aid the home side to get a result.
A quick word for the Arsenal travelling support here, by the way. With TNT Sport once more taking the absolute mickey out of match-attending supporters for the second weekend in a row - having last week scheduled Newcastle vs Bournemouth for a 12.30pm kick-off that would have meant away fans having to leave at 1am to be sure of getting to Tyneside on time - by obliging those Arsenal fans who had been in Italy just three days prior to head 200+ miles north to a city which left them no visible means of getting back home via public transport after the match. Why this sort of thing is permitted by the authorities, I simply do not know!
Anyhoo... let's get into it. And Mikel reverted to the eleven who started against Chelsea the previous weekend; with the other change worthy of note being the return of Jurrien Timber to the bench. Sunderland was a difficult place to go last season, and looks like being equally difficult this season for any opponent. Especially bearing in mind that up until Saturday they had actually allowed the opposition fewer shots on target than even Arsenal in their first three matches!
In the early stages, Arsenal were faced with the lowest of possible low blocks, with space at an absolute premium in and around the home penalty area and Sunderland's tactics clear; deny space, and whenever possible hoof the ball up to the wall-like Brobbey for him to hold the ball up as long as possible to allow players to get around and support him. Brobbey's first act, probably inevitably, was to flatten Konsa, and the pair had a running battle all evening.
However, it didn't take long for a patient Arsenal to fashion an excellent opportunity, when in the 14th minute Rice's delicate chip found the onrushing Saka just 6 yards out. Starboy appeared to be wearing the same boots as he was wearing in Naples - i.e. NOT his shooting boots - as he only managed to prod the ball gently into Roefs' arms.
But Sunderland did start to feel their way into the game and get up the pitch; their first opportunity came when Konsa fouled Brobbey (running theme...) and Granit Xhaka's magnificent dead ball flew dangerously between the Arsenal defensive line and David Raya. Ballard's contact wasn't clean enough to cause any issue, however. Nevertheless, apart from the occasional foray from the home side, Arsenal were very much in control.
A second decent chance came and went as a typically intricate move down the away side's left saw Odegaard cut the ball back for Havertz; who could only scoop his shot over the bar from 8 yards out. Moments later the ubiquitous Odegaard, once more pulling all the strings for Arsenal and looking like the league's best player so far, crossed from the right for Havertz to chest the ball down and volley spectacularly with his back to goal; but directly above Roefs, who turned the ball over the bar comfortably. Still 0-0, but it could have already been 0-3 - and by half-time may have been 4, as only a clever intervention with his heel from Xhaka prevented Havertz from converting a late Saka corner.
At the resulting corner, by the way, Brobbey hurled Calafiori to the ground - but referee Brooks - who had been allowing all sorts of robust challenges from the home side to go unpunished (Arsenal don't like it up 'em - tick...) - waved play on (it's OK if they do it TO Arsenal players - tick...). Mikel Arteta, who went over to the fourth official to remonstrate, was then booked by Brooks for doing so (typical Arteta - tick...). Pathetic...
But the half-time scoreline... Brian Brobbey's extremely wide posterior 0, Arsenal 0.
And Arteta took action during the break, with Timber replacing White (who had been holding his groin late on) and Bruno on for MLS. The latter a very popular decision for the home supporters, obviously... and the game continued as before the break - with Arsenal dominating the ball, but Sunderland looking capable on the break - with Brobbey continuing to cause Konsa and Gabriel problems. And on 54 minutes.. penalty to Sunderland!
A preposterous call. And to understand why it was preposterous, let's go through the guidelines/triggers for awarding a penalty:
- Focus on the opponent: the defender focuses entirely on the rival player instead of tracking the ball. In this instance, Konsa's eyes are on the ball until such time as he is dragged down by Ballard
- No attempt to play the ball: the defender makes no genuine effort to challenge for or play the ball. Impossible for Konsa to play the ball - Ballard drags him down before he can get off the ground
- Two-armed holds: the defender uses both arms to grab, wrap around, or restrict an attacker. Konsa has one hand on Ballard; has to use the other to attempt to keep his balance as the latter grabs his jersey
- Turned backs: the defender deliberately blocks or restricts an attacker who has their back turned to an incoming set-piece. Both players are facing the ball
- Sustained impact: the holding or shirt-pulling lasts long enough to noticeably impede the opponent's ability to move. It is Ballard who drags Konsa down on top of him
I mean... it's not even close to being a penalty. Not one of the above criteria are met. In fact, it's Ballard who drags Konsa over his hip.
So for the VAR conversation to go:
Brooks: 'He's all over him at the near post facing the wrong way'
Atwell (VAR): 'I'm happy that it's a holding offence. Confirming the on-field decision of penalty'
Absolute nonsense! And so we go back to the conspiracy theories. Because just two games ago Arsenal were denied a penalty themselves following Maatsen's scissor kick assault on Saka at Villa Park. What, precisely, are Arsenal and their supporters supposed to think?
But there it was. Le Fee lining up the spot kick, with David Raya to beat. And I'll tell you this: I had a sense that the penalty was going to be low to Raya's left, and that the goalkeeper was going to dive the right way and save it. Which is precisely what transpired. And what a brilliant save it was! The instant reaction from the Arsenal players was as much about the injustice of the penalty award as it was the save. And this is precisely why you have to rate David Raya so highly - because he saves the team time and again with crucial interventions and saves. This one, hot on the hells of the Estevao shot that he tipped over last weekend, show why he is possibly Arsenal's greatest ever goalkeeper. It's moments like these, that Raya has been delivering for year after year, that change the trajectory of a season.

Two minutes later, and Arsenal had the lead. Bruno Guimares rifling in a 20 yard effort into the top corner of Roefs' net. Justice done. Disallow that, Sonny Jim! Anguish for the home supporters, as the former Newcastle captain makes a telling contribution. Enjoyable celebration too, by the way...
From then - I have to be honest - I had an almost surreal sense of calm. Rightly or wrongly, anyway. No way were Arsenal going to let this slip, I was thinking. Not this time. Not this year. Lightning was never going to strike twice. This group of players are built differently. Although my confidence was tested on a few occasions, I have to admit.
But if anything, Arsenal could and should have pulled away. Saka missed another presentable opportunity. Havertz had a header cleared off the line by Ballard. And the German passed when he had an excellent shooting chance. Then Timber buried Odegaard's free kick; a tight call for offside.
Despite the old fashioned 'up and under' pressure from the home side Raya was rarely threatened... until very late on, that is, when new signing Malick Fofana began to bring havoc to Arsenal's right side and we saw some penalty box pinball, and some major havoc following a Xhaka cross when Raya had to intervene twice in order to clear the danger.
In the meantime, Brooks had excelled himself yet again. This time penalising Calafiori for taking too long to get the ball back into play at a throw-in (Arsenal deliberately delay restarts - tick...). Except that he was letting Sunderland do it all game. And then a booking for Gabriel, who had been looking to act as peacemaker following an incident between Konsa and Mukiele (Gabriel always instigates trouble. I've got to punish him - tick...)
The icing went on the cake late on, as deep into injury time Saka was a warded a penalty. Reinaldo - previously booked for tugging Saka's shirt - got his marching orders, having dragged him back inside the penalty area. Spot kick low to the keeper's left again; but this time there was too much power for Roefs to keep it out.
Three more points tucked away, then, at a ground where many teams are sure to struggle. Sunderland are here to stay; that I can confidently predict. And this means that Arsenal now find themselves 5 points ahead of where they were from comparative games last season. You will recall the late loss at Villa, and the late concession leading to a draw at the Stadium of Light. That'll do.
Before I go; two things. Firstly, victory in Naples. Never an easy place to go, yet Arsenal dominated almost throughout. Two words of caution, however.
Firstly, Naples did have a few chances on the break. As did Sunderland, And as had Chelsea. I'd suggest that Arsenal are riding their luck somewhat as they look to 'attack' this season. It is very possible that a combination of a little bit too much risk-taking, and a perceived lack of fire power and true star quality up top, may hurt them as the season progresses. I am sure that Arteta is aware of this.
Secondly, there is the question of Ebereche Eze on the left wing. Arsenal dominated completely, and at a suffocatingly slow pace I must add. But I certainly felt that they were inhibited by Eze's unwillingness to even attempt to go to the outside of his full back He wants to play more in the interior, so he doesn't feel like a natural alternative to Tzolis. Maybe it'll have to be the left-footed Madueke?
Finally - and I cannot let this pass - there is the actual biggest refereeing controversy of the weekend. Which is the goal awarded to Manchester City at Old Trafford. All I can say is this: there is no way that ANYBODY who has played or watched football at any level can possibly think that Enzo Fernandez is not offside and 'interfering with play' as he launches himself at Cherki's cross inside the 6-yard box, directly in front of the goalkeeper and with the lone defender drawn to him instead of staying with Haaland at the back post. I have seen some diabolical officiating decisions in my time, but for the referee and VAR to go through the process they did and come up with Goal as the answer takes the absolute biscuit. It's simply unfathomable - but I'm sure that United will take solace in the inevitable 'apology' As if the decision to send off Foden, and not book Rat Face Fernandes, wasn't enough of an egregious error earlier on.

When will it stop, and no wonder that Arsenal fans feel that there's corruption in the air as City continue to keep pace with the Champions. Simply unbelievable, and it is clear to me that PRO Ref (new name for PGMOL; same old sh*t though) are completelt unfit for purpose. Just look at how UEFA and FIFA run their competitions for comparison.
Anyway, Arsenal move on; masters - hopefully - of their own destiny. Ipswich away in the Carabao Cup on Tuesday (I'm expecting full rotation) and then another tricky game at Brighton on Saturday before the tumbleweed of an extended Interlull beckons.
Let's keep going. COYG!